Who Makes Better Wine - California Or France?

So full disclosure, I'm not a native of Californiatradition. In many parts of France winemaking has
(although by some accounts I should be counted asnot changed much, if at all in the 1,600 years wine
such), but I've lived here for the past twenty twohas been being made there. Often Americans are
years....so I am partial to big, robust, powerful winesshocked by their wine tasting experiences in France
from Napa and Sonoma.because they arrive to find an old musty, dirty wine
For the record, this is the classic comparison in thecellar that is producing some of the greatest wine
wine industry, largely because Bordeaux and Napa arethey have ever had the opportunity to taste. They
the two preeminent wine regions in the world todayare also shocked when they find that tasting often
and both focus on exactly the same type of grapes.comes directly from the barrel, with any unused wine
The differences are vast between the winesbeing poured back into the barrel.
themselves though, largely because of the conditionsCompare this type of picture to what you can find in
that they are grown and produced in. To startNapa where wineries have state of the art facilities. I
weather is a vital concern in France as their grapesdo find it interesting that perhaps the most
can, in some years, struggle to reach full ripenessexpensive facility in Napa, Vineyard 29, has spent so
because of inopportune cold spells in the summer. Inmuch money in order to produce wine in the most
Napa, there is no such cause for concern. Thehistoric way possible. Their goal is to have a wine
summers are almost always hot during the day andmade without pumps, totally gravity driven....which
mild at night, perfect ripening conditions for grapesdespite all this technology is amazingly similar to what
like Cabernet Sauvignon.the French winemakers produce on a yearly basis in
All of this is not to say that colder weather makestheir antiquated facilities.
for bad wine, in fact far from it. Many people, myselfAdd it all up, which wines do I prefer? Simple,
included, believe that grapes which need to workdepends on what I am eating. Honestly I do enjoy a
harder to ripen often carry more intense flavorsgreat Bordeaux, especially when paired well with
because they grow in small quantities as well as infood, while I find it hard to believe that anything
smaller bunches.tastes better with a piece of grilled meat then a
The biggest difference between the two regions isgreat California Cabernet Sauvignon.